The Value of Civics in the Classroom
Dr. Brooke Blevins has seen for herself what can happen when students are taught to take civic action. She’s thrilled with the results.
“Without civic engagement, civic knowledge only does so much good,” said Blevins, co-director of Baylor’s iEngage Summer Institute.
Whether it’s a donation drive to collect supplies for abused children, a young woman playing in her school’s male-dominated tackle football league, or just the number of students who return to her program year after year, Blevins is surrounded by the lasting effects of action-based civic learning.
K–12 educators have an opportunity to do the same: guide and teach students how to be active members of democracy far beyond election season.
While voting is one of the most obvious forms of civic participation, most K–12 students are too young to participate. However, age-appropriate civics education doesn’t seem to be hitting the mark, either.
Fewer than a quarter of eighth-graders tested proficient or higher on the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) civics exam External link in 2016. Even students with advanced curriculum are coming up short: The average score on the AP Government and Politics exam is among the lowest of all 47 AP exams, and barely more than half of students pass.
The percentage of 12th-grade students who volunteer saw a 12-point increase between 1991 and 2016. More than 36 percent of 12th-graders volunteered at least once a month in 2016, compared to 33 percent of 10th-graders and 28 percent of 8th-graders.
What Is Action Civics?
Action civics addresses root causes of community issues and encourages students to examine why an issue exists in the first place.
Blevins uses animals as an example: If the issue is the number of animals in shelters, then adopting every cat and dog might seem like a solution. But it doesn’t really address the root cause: Why are so many animals in shelters? Why aren’t people adopting them?
The final step of the action civics process addresses next steps: What are we going to do to address this issue?
“Our goal is to move students from just thinking about citizenship as being personally responsible to being something that's more robust,” Blevins said. “We want to encourage students to get other people involved in helping solve root causes and deal with systemic or policy related issues.”
Megan Brandon, regional program manager at Generation Citizen, said her organization believes in focusing students in on an issue and its root cause before funneling them back out into action through their advocacy hourglass.
“By the end of the semester [teachers] say, ‘That was really powerful. That was a good chance for our students to take a concept they had learned and actually be able to apply it,’” Brandon said.
What Are Some Challenges Educators Face When Teaching Civics?
Incorporating new lessons and action-driven takeaways can seem daunting, or even impossible, for educators who are already short for time in the classroom — especially when so many students aren’t getting these lessons anywhere else.
Only Maryland and the District of Columbia require service learning in order for students to graduate high school — and there are 10 states that do not include a year of U.S. government or civics as part of the mandatory curriculum.
While 40 states and the District of Columbia have civics course requirements for high school students, only Maryland and the District of Columbia have community service requirements.
“The biggest worry that we find across the board ... it’s really time,” Brandon said. “[Teachers’] time with students‚ their time to cover content, it’s so limited.”
But Brandon said that often these lessons can fit into existing curriculum more easily than teachers expect, as long as they stay flexible and have an open mind. She recommends incorporating civics into existing curriculum where it fits best for each teacher and each class.
Another common worry among educators is that teaching civics will inherently bring up politics. Blevins said any attempt to keep things apolitical is impossible because nothing is apolitical, but framing issues as a conversation is important. She encouraged educators to remind students that there are more than two sides to every issue, that everyone is influenced by their own beliefs, and that it’s important to take these things into consideration when addressing root causes.
Introductory Toolkit for Action Civics Education
Below, Baylor University’s online doctorate of education program has collected tips, resources, and ideas for teachers looking to incorporate action civics lessons into their curriculum.
Action Civics Education: Teach
Incorporate lessons on the basic tenets of citizenship and democracy. There’s a lot to learn about how government works and the history of U.S. government, but start with concepts that are foundational to the idea of active citizenship.
Frame every lesson with a follow-up action. For example:
What is consensus building and how can we accomplish it?
What is a political platform and how should we read it?
Who represents us in local government and how can I contact them?
- Share My Lesson: Created by the American Federation of Teachers and TES Global, this award-winning online community is committed to providing high-quality and effective lesson plans, free online professional development and opportunities for educator collaboration. Topics span the preK-12 curriculum and include curated collections on civic education resources like Constitution Day, The Supreme Court and Foundations of Democracy.
- iCivics: Founded by Justice Sandra Day O’Connor, iCivics includes free games and lesson plans to teach students of all ages about all areas of citizenship and government. Topics include the federal budget, our nation’s courts, elections, and more.
- National Archives Educator Resources: From the official federal records administration, this site includes an online tool for teaching with primary documents.
- Street Law Inc.: This free resource library has a collection of case summaries, mock trials, and lesson plans focused on our nation’s court system.
- Newseum Ed: Provided by the Newseum as a free resource to educators, this site is a collection of artifacts, debates and lesson plans mostly centered around the First Amendment and freedom of the press.
Action Civics Education: Partner
Invite local leaders into your classroom to speak with students about issues that matter to them. Politicians, public servants, community leaders and other experts can contribute to the conversation.
“One of your greatest resources is your community,” Blevins said. “The biggest change happens in communities when people join together to create coalitions and to work together to solve issues.
Learn how organizations can provide resources and training materials for your classroom. Some examples include:
Action Civics Education: Act
Provide opportunities for students to practice action civics in a classroom setting. With experiential learning, students can put their new skills to use to try and solve real-world problems.
- Practice electoral engagement with a student-led mock election. For many students, this can be their first introduction to voting, political platforms and group-stakes decision-making.
- Advocacy projects allow students to identify, research and problem-solve an issue from beginning to end. Let them choose a problem that resonates with them and develop an action plan to respond.
- Blevins utilizes the “Shark Tank” model: She invites local experts and community leaders to hear advocacy pitches from students and provide feedback.
Blevins said that framing citizenship as a group effort is important and can have a lasting positive effect on students’ motivations to act.
“Young people see that they don’t have to do it alone,” she said. “There are already people working on issues they may care about that they could partner with in order to create change or learn how they can create their own organizations and make that change.”
Find more resources on civics education and social justice issues in Share My Lesson's curated collection of free resources and lesson plans.