Joshua Cowen, a professor of education policy at Michigan State University, said that AI’s role in education will continue to develop over time, namely as a research tool. “If you can help [students] find a way to use AI for fact-finding for research, with the proper guardrails there for interacting with the kinds of content they would get online, there’s some positive things they can get from that,” he said.
But as the use of AI rises in schools, so do the concerns.
A study from the Brookings Institution found that the risks AI poses greatly outweigh the benefits. It’s easy for students to become too dependent on AI and “offload” their critical thinking to a chatbot—a concern Weingarten raised as well. Students who frequently use large language models like ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini to generate information or solve problems may weaken their cognitive development.
Sari Beth Rosenberg, a longtime U.S. history teacher at the High School for Environmental Studies in New York City, said she sees more of her students using AI. She has no problem with them using AI technology to do research, but using it to do their work for them is crossing the line.
“The issue is that kids will always find ways to cut corners and cheat,” she said. “There are a lot of responsibilities on their plates as students—they have sports and jobs, and they want to do well in school. But the problem is that if they just rely on AI, then they’re never actually going to prepare themselves for the job force and their lives outside of school.”
Lawmakers across the political aisle have taken note of AI’s harmful effects too. This year, legislators in more than 30 states proposed over 130 bills focused on implementing more human oversight of AI in schools. In addition, at least 38 states have put forth policies to restrict or ban cellphones in classrooms, according to EdWeek.
“We need a relentless, intentional focus on what our young people need: greater literacy, numeracy and civic engagement, and active learning that excites and engages them—all while ensuring their social and mental well-being and ability to form healthy relationships. Devices down, eyes up, hands-on,” Weingarten said.