Define Impeachment: Two Experts Discuss a Controversy
House Speaker Nancy Pelosi formally announced the beginning of a formal impeachment inquiry on Tuesday, Sept 24th, after a whistleblower alleged that the president tried to influence a foreign leader to aid his reelection. Syndicated columnist Mark Shields and New York Times columnist David Brooks join Judy Woodruff to define impeachment and explore the roots of the recent inquiry, including the details of the phone call between President Trump and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy and the inquiry’s potential effects on the 2020 election. Read the summary, watch the video below (transcript here) and answer the discussion questions.
Discussion Questions to Help Define Impeachment
1) Essential question: What does the impeachment inquiry say about the political process in the U.S.?
2) What happens during an impeachment inquiry? (check out Ted-Ed’s How does impeachment work? – Alex Gendler)
3) Why has Congress reacted to the formal impeachment inquiry in a partisan way? What arguments are you hearing from Democratic and Republican officials?
4) David Brooks states:
“And, to me, the decision to do impeachment is a mistake.
They — I do agree Trump did something impeachable, but this is a political process, not a legal process. There’s no obligation to prosecute.
And, to me, it’s a mistake for a couple reasons. If your object is to get Donald Trump out of the White House, impeachment doesn’t get you there, because the chance that you will get 20 senators, 20 Republican senators, to vote to vote Donald Trump out of office seems to me so remote, it’s minuscule.
So the likely outcome of this is that Donald Trump will say, see, I was acquitted in the Senate. I’m vindicated. I beat these people…
In the meantime, you’re trampling over your Democratic primary season. You’re not having the debate the voters want, which is about climate change and health care and jobs and stuff like that.
You’re focusing all the attention on the Democratic side, or the bulk of it, to the Congress, not to the presidential candidates
Do you agree or disagree with Brooks’s assessment? Explain.
5) Mark Shields states:
“I mean, what it puts to rest is the lie about the confidence of the Trump campaign: We’re leading in all polls. We’re ahead.
He was so terrified, so intimidated, the president of the United States got on the phone with the leader of Ukraine to get dirt on the one Democrat who in every major poll was beating him and that candidate’s son.
I mean, this shows the terror, the intimidation. And the false bravado is just totally exposed… This is a country, Judy, that has a smaller army than that of Sri Lanka. I mean, it’s sitting on the doorstep of Russia, that has shown nothing but imperial totalitarian impulses toward it, translated into physical action. It’s got an economy smaller than that of El Salvador. And we’re holding $451 million?
And the president of the United States — it’s a supplicant, mendicant. It’s the boss to the lowest employee. I mean, the power is totally disproportionate. And anybody has to acknowledge that who sees it.”
Do you agree or disagree with Shields’ assessment? Explain.
6) Media literacy: Read the short article Who’s who in the Trump impeachment inquiry? Who would you add to the list?
7) How would you define impeachment?
Define Impeachment: Extension Activities
- Catch up on the first week of the news of the impeachment inquiry via NewsHour Extra here.
- Don’t forget to check out NewsHour Extra’s “Super Civics 2020” series for more resources on the 2020 election, including the article Will Trump impeachment strategy help 2020 Dems – or backfire?.
Explore impeachment lesson plans and resources in Share My Lesson's curated collection.
This article was originally published by PBS NewsHour Extra and can be found here.